St. Maarten Café
St. Maarten Café served cheese fries and cold beer on Wertland Street off the Corner from 1985 to 2016, with regulars' pewter mugs hung in rows over the bar.
- Where
- Wertland Street, the Corner, Charlottesville, Virginia
- Open
- 1985–2016
- Known for
- Island-themed Corner bar with regulars' pewter mugs over the bar
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

An island bar off the Corner in 1985
St. Maarten Café opened in 1985 on Wertland Street, a little off the main run of bars on the Corner by the University of Virginia. It was named after the Caribbean island and set up to feel like an island getaway, and its full name was St. Maarten Cafe and Trading Co. Cvillepedia lists Jim Roland and Rusty Hilton as its founders; by 2012 it belonged to Jim Roland and his wife, Lisa.
The kitchen was known for Cajun cheese fries, wings at every level of heat and cheap beer specials. Unusually for a Corner bar, it drew as many Charlottesville locals as students, and alumni came back to it for decades.
The Coconut Club and its pewter mugs
The most loyal customers belonged to the Coconut Club. Members had a pewter mug engraved with their name or nickname, kept at the bar in a numbered slot and filled whenever they came in, and membership was for life. One alumna, Mary Katherine King, said you did not buy your way in: you earned a mug by coming often enough that the staff knew you by name, and she got her application on her 21st birthday.
The Trigon Engineering Society and the student drivers of University Transit Service both treated the place as an unofficial headquarters. A plaque listed Trigon's presidents, and the steering wheel from a UTS bus hung on the wall near the fish tank. Later on, Tuesday nights belonged to Geeks Who Drink trivia, and the UVA basketball player Joe Harris was among the students who came in.
“We were not a frat party establishment, more like the land of misfit toys.”
Closing in 2012, and the regulars who bought it
The Rolands chose to retire, and St. Maarten closed without warning on January 30, 2012, after 26 years. A Friends of St. Maarten Café group on Facebook had 350 members by that evening, and the next day people held a vigil outside the door and left flowers and cards. The owners said they were stunned by the reaction.
Soon afterwards a group of regulars bought the business. Tim Mulholland, an information technology executive, and four other alumni of the Trigon Engineering Society partnered with the bar's recent managers, Russ and Nicole Hamilton, as the New St. Maarten Trading Company. To raise start-up money they sold Founder Mug memberships at $500, each with a new 24-ounce mug. They reopened the café, added televisions and adjusted the specials, and ran it for several more years.
The last night in 2016
By the autumn of 2016 the kitchen could no longer cook properly, and the café was serving a limited menu. The Cavalier Daily reported that St. Maarten would close on Monday, October 31, 2016, after 31 years, in part because of expensive kitchen repairs; Virginia Magazine later recalled last call coming in November, after the season's final football game. Before it shut, the bar posted a mug reclamation notice and offered to return every Coconut Club member's mug, shipping them to members who could not come in for them.
Sources
- St. Maarten Cafe closes its doors (Elizabeth Cornick), The Cavalier Daily, October 31, 2016
- Just Around the Corner (Sarah Lindenfeld Hall), Virginia Magazine, Summer 2026
- St. Maarten Café set to re-open, The Hook, 2012, via Internet Archive
- St. Maarten Cafe, Cvillepedia
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of St. Maarten Café.
Share a memory of St. Maarten Café
The gift shop
The St. Maarten Café sign on a tee, hoodie and more. All St. Maarten Café pieces

