Skip to content

Pete Miller's

A Sherman Avenue steakhouse in Evanston that put on live jazz with no cover for 25 years, from 1994 until it closed without warning on August 19, 2019.

Where
1557 Sherman Avenue, downtown Evanston, Illinois
Open
1994–2019
Known for
Steakhouse with free live jazz every night
Reading time
2 minutes
The Pete Miller's sign, redrawn
The Pete Miller's sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

A steakhouse named for a jazz fan

Pete Miller's opened in 1994 at 1557 Sherman Avenue in downtown Evanston, in a space that had been a Bennigan's for nearly ten years and, before that, Smithfield's grocery. It took its name from Harold "Pete" Miller, a Second World War veteran with a Purple Heart and a jazz-loving regular at the Davis Street Fishmarket.

The Fishmarket's owners, the Clean Plate Club restaurant group, which also ran Merle's Smokehouse downtown, owned Pete Miller's. It was a steakhouse with a separate jazz lounge, a stage, its own sound system and lights, and it billed itself as a four-star restaurant.

Live jazz with no cover

For 25 years Pete Miller's had live jazz and never charged a cover. The guitarist Bobby Broom started playing there in 1996 and kept a weekly night for about 15 years; his trio's live album The Way I Play, Live in Chicago was recorded on Wednesday nights in 2008. Kurt Elling and José Valdez were among the other musicians on its stage. Broom's wife, Maureen, started on the lunch shift as a waitress, became general manager, and ran the room from about 2002 to 2010, training staff to tell diners about the music and to respect the players. She also booked the Jump and Verve Jazz Festival at Fountain Square, run with the Evanston Chamber of Commerce, which presented McCoy Tyner, Stanley Turrentine, Dr. John and Paquito D'Rivera.

With no cover, the bar drew the jazz students coming up through Chicago-area programmes, Broom wrote, many of them short of money. Under-21s could not sit at the bar but could sit in the jazz lounge, and in 2003 manager Ty Dassler told the Daily Northwestern the restaurant got a lot of Northwestern music students.

“We've seen one of the best years on record”

Wheeling and the later years

In the summer of 2003 the owners opened a second Pete Miller's at 412 North Milwaukee Avenue in Wheeling, about twice the size of the Evanston room, with jazz, pool and a crowd of suburban diners and corporate parties. In 2011 Sonas Hospitality Group bought the business from Clean Plate. Sonas also ran the Midnight Pig Taproom next door on Sherman Avenue.

The last night in August 2019

Pete Miller's in Evanston served its last meals on Monday, August 19, 2019, and the Midnight Pig closed with it. Sonas had decided to leave the restaurant business. Staff had been told the owners were looking for new investors, but learned of the closing only on the last day of service. Forty-two people lost their jobs. General manager Cory Robinson said business had been strong, with a record summer.

Former staff started a #SavePetes campaign to find a buyer for the name before the space had to be cleared at the end of the month. The building had already been listed for sale that July by Westley Realty Group, for $400,000. The campaign did not bring Pete Miller's back to Sherman Avenue, and the Wheeling branch has since closed as well.

Sources

  1. Pete Miller's closes; staff aim to save Evanston jazz institution (August 22, 2019), Evanston Patch
  2. The Melodies Lingered On (Bobby Broom, August 2019), bobbybroom.com
  3. Pete Miller's branches out with Wheeling steakhouse (Greg Lowe, September 2003), The Daily Northwestern
  4. Pete Miller's Seafood and Prime Steak, Wheeling (permanently closed), OpenTable

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Pete Miller's.

Share a memory of Pete Miller's

The gift shop

The Pete Miller's sign on a tee, hoodie and more. All Pete Miller's pieces