Skip to content

Jagger's

Jagger's served square pan pizza and wings to Emory students from 1972, first in an Emory Village tavern, then from Sage Hill on Briarcliff Road until 2012.

Where
North Decatur Road, Emory Village, Atlanta; from 2008 at 1799 Briarcliff Road, Sage Hill Shopping Center, Atlanta
Open
1972–2012
Known for
Square pan pizza and wings by Emory
Reading time
2 minutes
The Jagger's sign, redrawn
The Jagger's sign, redrawn by Moonshadows Studios from photos of the original

Bill Jagger opens in Emory Village in 1972

Jagger's was the work of Bill Jagger, a Detroit native who lived in Decatur and held a Ph.D. In 1972, according to a 2008 Creative Loafing profile by Thomas Wheatley, he decided he would rather talk philosophy with college students over pizza and beer than work in a university, and he opened a tavern on North Decatur Road in Emory Village, the small shopping strip at the edge of the Emory University campus. Tomorrow's News Today, an Atlanta restaurant news blog, placed it almost on top of Everybody's Pizza, the Village's other pizza house.

The place was a bar first. Wheatley, who ate there every weekend as a child, remembered a room that smelled of beer, and a blogger who wrote about it in 2008 called it the little tavern where the writer's whole crowd met at one time or another.

Atlanta-style square pizza and wings

The pizza was baked in a pan and cut into rectangles, with a toasted edge and a heavy cover of Wisconsin brick cheese, a style Jagger's sold as Atlanta-style pizza. A reader of Tomorrow's News Today said it was the only pizzeria in town that used the name. The sauce was mildly sweet and the pies rose thick; the restaurant's later website boasted that its large pizza carried more than a pound of cheese. Wings were the other house speciality, sold in three sauces named Jaggers Daggers, Jaggers Creepers and Jagger's Peepers, from very hot to lemon pepper.

The website also claimed that Jagger's had won the only real pizza contest the Atlanta Journal-Constitution ever held. Creative Loafing said the place won a number of awards in its first 27 years and drew a following of neighbours and Emory students.

A sale in 1999 and a new start at Sage Hill

Bill Jagger sold the restaurant in 1999, and the Emory Village Jagger's closed in 2005. A restaurant review guide, Gayot, later wrote that Park Bench, at 1577 North Decatur Road at Oxford Road, had once been Jagger's, kept the old wooden booth and table in the front window that generations of Emory students knew, and still served the Jagger deep-dish pizza. Gayot does not say when Park Bench took over the room.

In 2008 Jagger's came back in a small storefront at 1799 Briarcliff Road in the Sage Hill Shopping Center, not far from the Village. It began as a pick-up and delivery shop. Creative Loafing reported that Jagger stopped in every day to taste a slice and wanted to add tables and a bar; by 2009 the shop's website billed it as a restaurant and tavern and offered Emory students 15 percent off with their ID.

Jagger's closes in August 2012

The Sage Hill Jagger's closed in the last week of August 2012. Tomorrow's News Today reported the closing on 31 August, and Patch repeated it the same evening. Neither gave a reason. The space was to reopen within days as Pizza Bella, under different owners, serving round pizzas instead of square ones. For some days afterwards the Jagger's sign stayed up, and the phone was answered as Pizza Bella, formerly Jagger's.

Emory Magazine's 2013 essay on the lost businesses of Emory Village, by John Mills, listed Jagger's alongside Horton's Sundries, Oliver's Pharmacy and Everybody's Pizza, noting that it had reopened and closed again at Sage Hill.

Sources

  1. Cheap Eats - Jagger's: Nexus of nostalgia, Creative Loafing Atlanta
  2. Decades Long Emory Favorite Closes, New Concept Coming Soon, Tomorrow's News Today
  3. Jagger's Pizza Closes, Virginia Highland-Druid Hills Patch
  4. Coda: Vestiges of Emory Village, Emory Magazine
  5. Park Bench (closed), Gayot
  6. Food, griftdrift (blog)
  7. Jagger's Restaurant and Tavern (archived website, 2009), Internet Archive

From the regulars

Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Jagger's.

Share a memory of Jagger's

The gift shop

The Jagger's sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Jagger's pieces