Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale
Charlie Saunders's downtown Minneapolis restaurant at Fourth Avenue South and Seventh Street, known for its potato salad and run to the end by Louise Saunders.
- Where
- 701 Fourth Avenue South at Seventh Street, downtown Minneapolis
- Open
- 1933–1982
- Known for
- Downtown Minneapolis dining rooms famous for a secret potato salad
- Reading time
- 4 minutes

Two Charlies open on Fourth Avenue South in 1933
Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale opened in downtown Minneapolis in 1933, the year Prohibition ended. It was named for two men. Charles Saunders had been a waiter, and Charles Herlin, known as Charlie the Finn, was a bartender with a following of his own. Herlin's best-known drink was the President, made with gin, orange, lemon and a dash of grenadine. He died soon after the doors opened, and Saunders carried on as sole owner.
The first address was 716 Fourth Avenue South. A linen postcard from those years shows a two-storey house with a blue roof, a long blue awning out to the curb and Saunders's portrait and signature, over the slogan "America's Most Talked About and Unique Cafe". James Lileks, who catalogued the cafe's matchbooks, wrote that it opened in December 1933 and that a filet mignon then cost a dollar.

The white brick building at Seventh Street
After the war Saunders built a new restaurant across the street, on the corner of Fourth Avenue South and Seventh Street. Lileks dates the move to 1948 and an addition to 1958. A promotional piece for "the New Charlie's" described the design as French Provincial and dated it to 1949. Others have called the white brick building, with its steep slate roof, English Tudor. Inside were oak panelling, low beamed ceilings and stone fireplaces. A later postcard names the rooms: the Hunt Room, the English Room, the Oak Room, the Coach Room and a cocktail lounge with a long curved bar. There was music most nights. A 1939 advertisement for the earlier house promised Rollie Altmeyer at the Hammond organ and Eunice Johnson singing requests, and the later building kept a piano bar.
In a niche by the front door stood a bronze fountain figure of a nude water nymph about six feet tall, called Scherzo, by the sculptor Harriet Frishmuth. One local history says it had first stood in a roof garden at the Foshay Tower and was later sold to a private owner.
Holiday magazine gave the restaurant its dining award year after year. One of Charlie's own postcards claims 20 of them and a later one 26. James Beard wrote that it was the Minneapolis restaurant most frequented by men, and praised its freshwater fish, its beef and its breads. Wikipedia lists Bob Hope, Jack Dempsey and Richard Nixon among the people who ate there. The columnist and WCCO radio host Cedric Adams, a close friend of Saunders, was in so often that the lunch menu carried a Cedric Adams sandwich of turkey and mushrooms in cream sauce on toast.
“This business is constantly with you; I can only get away from it when I'm in a tough bridge game.”

A 1953 discrimination case at Charlie's
In 2015 the Star Tribune's Rick Nelson found a 1953 clipping from the Minneapolis Spokesman in the paper's archive. It reported that Charlie's turned away parties that included Black guests by claiming to have no record of their reservations. On the day in question Frank Fager, executive secretary of the Mayor's Council on Human Relations, arrived for lunch with the Rev. George Siudy and Clifford Rucker, the Black executive secretary of the Governor's Interracial Commission. The host said he could not find the booking. When Fager began asking other diners whether they had needed reservations, two bouncers put him out through the kitchen.
The Spokesman called Charlie's the last top restaurant in the city still discriminating, and the local NAACP board voted to act. The same story recalled that Hubert Humphrey, as mayor in the 1940s, had answered an earlier complaint by walking into the main dining room for lunch with William Seabron of the Urban League. Nelson could find no follow-up in the daily papers.
Louise Saunders and the potato salad
Saunders had a heart attack in 1961 and stepped back. He had married Louise, a lawyer, in 1959. The Star Tribune gives his death as 1964, and one local history gives 1962. Louise Saunders gave up her law practice to run the restaurant, and ran it for the rest of its life.
A Minneapolis Star reporter who spent two days behind the scenes in 1975 counted 358 seats, 221 of them in the upstairs banquet rooms, about 175 employees, a payroll of more than $1 million and some 320,000 meals a year. The restaurant had its own bakery and butcher shop. The maitre d', Henry Bathke, seated as many as 700 people on a busy evening. The beverage manager, Joe Peterson, had been there 40 years and grew the mint for the juleps in his back yard. The executive chef, George Lisovskis, had started in 1955.
The dish people remembered was the potato salad. Requests for the recipe reached the Star Tribune's food section for more than 20 years. The restaurant gave a version to Better Homes & Gardens in 1963 and to the newspaper in 1975. When the paper reprinted it in 1989, Louise Saunders telephoned to say it was wrong. She said only she and two others knew the real one, and that the kitchen made the salad in stages so that no employee saw the whole method. Lisovskis had said in 1971 that the difference was homemade mayonnaise with fresh eggs. After she died, a longtime manager suggested that the sweetness came from the juice of canned fruit.
Closing on July 21, 1982, and the 701 Building
Louise Saunders retired and closed the restaurant on July 21, 1982, in its 49th year, and sold the corner to a developer. An office tower, the 701 Building, stands there now. She died in 2003.
The bar and the frieze that hung behind it were kept in storage for four decades by the Minneapolis restaurateur John Rimarcik. In April 2022 the Minneapolis Club, a few blocks away at 729 Second Avenue South, installed both in a dining room it named Charlie's, opened for a limited run, with a menu drawn from the old ones by the chef Jamie Malone and the President back on the drinks list. The Twin Cities restaurant industry's annual prizes, the Charlie Awards, are also named for the cafe.

Sources
- Taste of the Past: Inside Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale (reprint of Peggy Katalinich, Minneapolis Star, Oct. 28, 1975), Star Tribune
- Strib memory lane: Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale, Star Tribune
- From the archives: A blemished past at Charlie's, Star Tribune
- The potato salad recipe that had the Twin Cities talking a while back, Star Tribune
- First look: Minneapolis Club ushers in a new era as its nod to Charlie's Cafe opens to the public, Star Tribune
- Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale, Wikipedia
- Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale, Twin Cities Music Highlights
- Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale (Matchbook Museum), Lileks.com
- The Cafe Exceptionale, Nokohaha
- Charlie's, The Minneapolis Club
- Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale postcards, Hennepin County Library, Wikimedia Commons
From the regulars
Were you there? Be the first to add a memory of Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale.
Share a memory of Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale
The gift shop
The Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale pieces



