Bonnie Brae Tavern
Carl and Sue Dire opened the Bonnie Brae Tavern on South University Boulevard in 1934. Their family served pizza and red sauce there for 88 years until 2022.
- Where
- 740 South University Boulevard, Bonnie Brae, Denver, Colorado
- Open
- 1934–2022
- Known for
- Family-run pizza and red-sauce tavern on University Boulevard
- Reading time
- 2 minutes

Carl and Sue Dire open on a dirt road in 1934
Carl and Sue Dire bought their lot on South University Boulevard in 1933, when the boulevard was still unpaved. Prohibition had just ended, and the area around it had been one of the driest parts of Denver. The couple opened their tavern there in 1934 and also ran a gas station on the corner.
They took the name from the Bonnie Brae housing development growing up around them. The Glendale Cherry Creek Chronicle, in a 2020 history of the place, gave the meaning of the Gaelic name as "pleasant hill." The building at 740 South University Boulevard went up the same year the tavern opened.
Pizza, red sauce and an hour's wait
The kitchen served red-sauce Italian and American food, and the tavern became best known for its pizza and beer. The Chronicle described it as a favourite of Glendale residents who thought of themselves as more country than city; well into the 1950s, many people regarded the corner as part of greater Glendale rather than Denver.
In the late 1970s and the 1980s, diners commonly waited about an hour for a table. The menu and the old-fashioned way of running the room changed very little over the decades, something the family later said may have left it behind as Denver's restaurant trends moved on. Regulars came back across generations: at the closing, longtime customer Terry Mendenhall told CBS Colorado the tavern had been a gathering place for five generations of her family, three of which were there on the last day.
“We just kept it true to what my grandfather's vision was.”
Three generations of the Dire family
Carl Dire died in 1982 and Sue Dire in 2002. The tavern stayed in the family. By its final years it was owned by their grandson Michael Dire and his cousin Ricky Dire. Michael had started working there about 40 years before it closed, after his father and uncle had worked there before him; Ricky had been on the staff since he was 15. Michael's three children also worked in the restaurant, managing and waiting tables, and had planned to take it over.
Taxes, the pandemic and the 2022 sale
Pressure on the business was public by early 2020. The family told the Chronicle that the property tax bill had jumped by $30,000 to $73,000, and plans had been filed for a three-story building with 43 apartments and street-level shops on the site. The city had already issued a certificate of demolition eligibility, valid until May 1, 2024.
The tavern kept going for two more years. The pandemic and a shortage of staff made things worse; the payroll fell from 32 employees to 14. At the end of May 2022 the family sold the tavern and the building next door for $4.5 million to Churchill Bunn of Alpine Investments and Rhys Duggan of Revesco Properties. Michael Dire told CBS that COVID had been the final blow. The Bonnie Brae Tavern served its last meals on Saturday, June 25, 2022, after 88 years.
What is planned for the site
The buyers announced a three-story apartment building with ground-floor retail on the half block at University Boulevard and Ohio Avenue, later marketed as Akin Bonnie Brae with 48 units. In 2022 the developers said they intended to keep the tavern's neon sign and some of its photographs as a tribute to the place.
Sources
- Neighborhood icon Bonnie Brae Tavern closes after 88 years, CBS Colorado
- After 86 Years, Three-Story Development Is About To Replace The Bonnie Brae Tavern, Glendale Cherry Creek Chronicle
- Two Of Denver's Dining Icons Close Their Doors, Glendale Cherry Creek Chronicle
- 'Very bittersweet': 88-year-old Bonnie Brae Tavern closing after sale to developers, BusinessDen
- Bonnie Brae Tavern closing after 88 years, BizWest
- Alpine Investments unveils plans for former Bonnie Brae Tavern site, Naked Denver
The gift shop
The Bonnie Brae Tavern sign on a tee, hoodie and more, each printed to order. All Bonnie Brae Tavern pieces











